Cuenca High Life logo

Ecuador News

Can bananas be saved? Science is working hard on a solution.

Editor’s note: As published in on September 2, Ecuador is the world’s top banana exporter, and there are more than 7,000 growers and 2.5 million jobs dependent on a healthy crop.

By Steven Savage, Ph.D.

As I wrote for Forbes in 2018, we might lose bananas as an affordable part of our diet. A dreaded new strain of a disease that has already severely hurt the industry in Australia and Africa has now been confirmed to have reached the Americas. Others have raised this alarm. This also happened in the mid-1900s when an earlier strain of this fungus wiped out the “Grand Nain” banana variety. That calamity made the 1923 song by Frank Silver and Irvin Cohn, “Yes, we have no bananas” sound prophetic. The great old Simon and Garfunkel song, “Slip-slidin Away” also comes to mind. The current “Cavendish” banana of commerce has a colorful history traveling through England of all places, but by chance, it was resistant to the first strain of the fungus. Unfortunately, the new, Tropical Race 4 strain has overcome that resistance. Once the fungus is introduced into a given plantation’s soil, there is no way to get rid of it. The industry tried really hard to keep the pest out, but all it takes to spread it is a bit of dirt on someone’s boot.

Sponsored ad

Now I’m sure some will say that this is all a problem because of “monoculture.” Yes, the whole commercial banana industry relies on very few varieties, but that isn’t something easily avoided as I explained in that earlier article. No one can do “conventional breeding” of bananas with any efficiency because, in case you hadn’t noticed, the bananas we like don’t have the big black, hard seeds of wild bananas. Remember the old kid’s song, “I love bananas because they have no bones!”

A devastating banana disease could threaten world harvests.

Bananas, wild or domesticated, reproduce very happily by making new sprouts, or “sons” around the base of the “mother tree.”  That basically means they are “cloned,” but so are most fruit crops. Bananas also provide their own “packaging” for food safety. There really isn’t any need to put them in a disposable plastic bag to bring them home from the store and even then they don’t need to be refrigerated.

It’s not like people haven’t tried to breed a new banana, but to get one that yields productively, can be ocean shipped (minimal carbon footprint) and then ripen as it approaches consumer sales has been a huge challenge as long as the breeders are handicapped by the anti-GMO thing.

In the late 1990s, I was involved in consulting projects for two of the biggest banana shippers. We were evaluating potential solutions that might be amenable to a biotech solution. We also evaluated the economics of those choices. However; once the anti-biotech activists figured out that they could intimidate brand-protective companies, the biotech banana projects were dropped before they really got started. It was sad.

So, shall we just resign ourselves to the eventual demise of this fruit? We certainly should appreciate it while we can, but there is a long-term solution. That solution is to fully employ the now even more advanced science of biotechnology. The tools and understanding today are vastly improved over what they were when we first considered this in the 90s. Indeed public sector scientists in Australia have already made some progress on this front. Yes, some will call this a, “gasp,” GMO, but I think it’s time to go there – past time really. Those who don’t want to accept the scientific truth about this can find some other fruit to eat. What isn’t fair is if they continue to block that freedom of choice for the rest of us.

Ok, but if we need make the jump to a biotech banana just have bananas, we might as well make a number of other changes for the benefit of those who grow this for us and for we as consumers. Here are the “upgrades” I would love to see for the banana crop for both rich nations like ours and also for poor people to depend on banana or plantain for a significant part of their diet. The efforts for the rich world market could pay for the work and those improved bananas could be given to poor farmers to grow for free.

Disease resistance

The “Fusarium Race 4” that just arrived in South America is the driving issue today, but there are other diseases for which a new solution would be fantastic.

There is a severe fungal disease that infects the leaves (Banana Sigatoka) and the crop has to be sprayed over and over throughout the season because if there is too much infection, the bananas won’t make the boat trip to our ports.

There is also a bacterial disease and several viruses. The viruses are an even bigger deal with key banana and plantain cultivars in places like sub-Saharan Africa. Some resistant lines have already been developed but rich-world activists have been largely successful in blocking their use where they are needed the most. One of the ways this disease has been achieved is through the use of “cisgenics.” That is the act of moving specific genes from wild Bananas into our preferred types. Basically, that is a way to tap into the considerable biodiversity that exists among wild bananas without bringing along the big hard seed issue.

Reduced Food Waste

As you have certainly experienced, bananas can move from green to yellow to black rather rapidly and that might mean throwing them out. One of the earliest ideas for biotech bananas was to stretch out that process by changing the expression levels of some of the genes related to the ripening process. The other big issue with bananas is bruising. It does not take much, including handling by your fellow shoppers, to elicit an injury response based on the enzyme polyphenol oxidase. This has already been done for apples and potatoes and I’m hoping we can start buying those options soon. By turning off that gene this major cause of food waste could be dramatically reduced. You could probably even start to see bananas offered on the “salad bar” at restaurants.

Nutritional enhancement

Bananas have already been developed that have enhanced levels of vitamin A, a nutrient that is unfortunately not that abundant in the diets of many poor people around the world. The “Golden Bananas”, like “Golden Rice” have also been largely blocked by the activists. I’d like to be able to buy such bananas and rice even though I have plenty of other sources of the vitamin in my food supply. It would be a solidarity thing with those who need it the most

So is it likely that the big, brand-sensitive banana companies will move ahead on this? I hope so because this is not just about their businesses. There are a lot of families in places like Central and South America whose livelihood depends on being to be able to help produce and pack this fruit. In many cases these are countries that also have terrible gang violence issues that are driving their people away. To lose this huge part of their nation’s income would only compound their suffering.

I think we should start a campaign to encourage the banana companies and the food retailers to muster the courage, the rationality, and the compassion to bring us a better banana. If they get started now the new options might be available in time as the Fusarium will inevitably spread. Maybe someone can modify the old tune to, “Yes, we will have bananas, we will have bananas today!”

Steve Savage, PhD, Plant Pathology, University of California, Davis. Dr. Savage has more than 30 years of experience in agricultural technology having worked in academics (Colorado State University), at a global research company (DuPont), at a biotechnology start-up (Mycogen), and for the last 16 years as a consultant. Over the years, his research and consulting topics have ranged from biological control to crop protection chemicals (synthetic and natural product-based); traits based on advances from traditional genetics to biotechnology; and crops from grains to specialty fruits and vegetables. He has also worked extensively on biofuels, fertilizers and on footprints of farming (carbon, water, energy, and land-use).



6 thoughts on “Can bananas be saved? Science is working hard on a solution.

  1. The seriousness of the banana fungus not withstanding, this writer does not appear to comprehend the serious issues with “bioteched food”.

    So great — apples and potatoes that do not bruise or rot — so you could be eating an “apple” that is a year or two old……bet there is lots of nutrition remaining in that apple next year. i have read that the farmers who plant the gmo potatoes make sure they plant real potatoes elsewhere that they personally eat.

    of course, there is no testing to see the real effects of the RNA changes on the human biome —guess they will see what illnesses pop up a year or two from now. Not to mention that the “bioteched” food is heavily sprayed with pesticides to kill the carbon based pests —-but they ignore the fact that the human body is carbon based and made up of more bacteria then cells that actually create a lot of the minerals and vitamins in the gut from the food it digests for us. So —kill the bacteria in the digestive tract (microbiome) so the bacteria that create the vitamins/minerals are gone………thus depriving the human body of minerals/vitamins so it is weakened and sickened —- Can’t imagine why over 50% of the US population has some type of chronic illness.

    Real Food is medicine and keeps the body healthy, not the fake phude this writer is pushing.

    1. I particularly liked the fact that only recently when Monsanto had been sold to Bayer can you touch them legally. All Germans and Jews know what Bayer is famous for…

  2. Sorry, but you can thank companies like Monsanto for the anti-GMO “activists.” Until GMO DOESN’T mean Roundup in my food, I’m all for Labeling my food and keeping your GMO’s out of it.

  3. Sounds like the same sales pitch (lie) we heard years ago with all the other GMO’s…. More vitamins, less rot. bigger, better, solve world hunger. It was all a lie…. except more profitable. GMO”s have gotten smaller (so you buy more) and sweeter (so you eat more). The only benefits they have offered is more profits to corporations and drug companies ! Maybe Mr. Savage should go back to the states to enjoy a complete GMO diet. Keep GMO’s out of South America !

Comments are closed.